CICADA 237

THE THIRD EDITION

The silence was not empty.

Two editions. Seven omissions. One reconstruction.

The manuscript survives in two forms. They disagree in places where neither appears to be damaged. The catalog describes a third edition. No complete copy has been recovered.

Begin with the discrepancy
Original black-ink engraving of a cicada beside its empty shed husk. The artwork carries no puzzle data.
FIG. 1 · SPECIMEN & EXUVIA
An original engraving

A Typographical Correction

Open Underprint

ALPHA · RETAINED WITNESS

Hollow chambers preserve an echo.

BETA · CURRENT WITNESS

Empty chambers preserve an echo.

The catalog calls these changes typographical. Both copies have been retained.

Editorial concordance

FOLIO 000 · CARRIER r1

Seven lines were retained at the front of both copies. Their numbering belongs to the plate, even when the text wraps.

Compare both witnesses
  1. I

    Archives, cell 1 preserved, cell 2 their, cell 3 imperfect, cell 4 witnesses, cell 5 against, cell 6 erasure, cell 7

  2. II

    A, cell 1 record, cell 2 so, cell 3 amended, cell 4 conceals, cell 5 its, cell 6 labor, cell 7

  3. III

    No, cell 1 editor, cell 2 restored, cell 3 what, cell 4 their, cell 5 predecessors, cell 6 could, cell 7

  4. IV

    Once, cell 1 we, cell 2 compared, cell 3 them, cell 4 silence, cell 5 became, cell 6 legible, cell 7

  5. V

    Those, cell 1 who, cell 2 return, cell 3 inherit, cell 4 no, cell 5 perfect, cell 6 witness, cell 7

  6. VI

    Our, cell 1 copies, cell 2 survived, cell 3 by, cell 4 preserving, cell 5 their, cell 6 disagreement, cell 7

  7. VII

    What, cell 1 you, cell 2 recover, cell 3 remains, cell 4 available, cell 5 for, cell 6 others, cell 7

A reading of the carrier

Recover the six instruments, or enter a reading you already know. Nothing requires six completion marks.

Stencil columns · by physical row

No reading has been applied. The original lines remain above.

    Consult a marginal note

    Apply the tools to the seven carrier lines already on the opening page.

    Read a more direct note

    Choose a column by physical row first, then arrange the chosen words in your correspondence order.